What is your worst Manics song ever?

[Deets]

Originally Posted by walpolian87

That's my favourite Manics song. I won't kill you though because I like you. I'll just injure you.

hehe do what you want, I won't change my opinion.

one more thing - great video - Kevin Carter, though I used to dislike this song too, but please don't listen to me, because I didn't like also Tolerate

[tzb]

Originally Posted by ditta

I really dislike Door To The River - you can kill me now

Happily. *obliges*

Such an amazing song!

[Simon]

what he said

Originally Posted by The Gutless Wonder

What's wrong with Autumnsong? It's absolutely fabulous!

I must agree! Yes the video/s are well random - but seriously, excellent tune!

[Slideling]

Originally Posted by Simon

I forgot how shit that video was.

Anyway, Autumnsong.

*glares at you as well*

[The Gutless Wonder]

Originally Posted by MSP1704

I must agree! Yes the video/s are well random - but seriously, excellent tune!

A fellow Autumnsong appreciater. I never thought the vid was as bad as people made out. Just needed the band in it maybe?

[Slideling]

Originally Posted by The Gutless Wonder

A fellow Autumnsong appreciater. I never thought the vid was as bad as people made out. Just needed the band in it maybe?

Yep. *agrees*

[Amanda]

Had a think about it, and as a current top 5 that appear on albums (one being absolute worst) I think mine goes like this, though I've probably forgotten something painfully obvious:

1. The Year of Purification - just cos live it was so painful, it would last forever without ever going anywhere or doing anything.

2. Be Natural - always found it painfully dull.

3. Nostalgic Pushead - its one of those ones where when it comes up on shuffle on your ipod its just embarrassing, but not in a makes you smile like looking at old photos way, just in an embarassing way.

4. Emily - never really got that one, I'm not sure if theres anything in particular about it I dislike, it just makes me want to hit the skip button.

5. My Guernica - just always seemed clumsy.

[lovesean4ever]

Originally Posted by Amanda

Had a think about it, and as a current top 5 that appear on albums (one being absolute worst) I think mine goes like this, though I've probably forgotten something painfully obvious:

1. The Year of Purification - just cos live it was so painful, it would last forever without ever going anywhere or doing anything.

2. Be Natural - always found it painfully dull.

3. Nostalgic Pushead - its one of those ones where when it comes up on shuffle on your ipod its just embarrassing, but not in a makes you smile like looking at old photos way, just in an embarassing way.

4. Emily - never really got that one, I'm not sure if theres anything in particular about it I dislike, it just makes me want to hit the skip button.

5. My Guernica - just always seemed clumsy.

YES YES YES to all those

[mafiamonroe]

I especially hate Emily for the way James sings charity as charidee.

[lovesean4ever]

Originally Posted by mafiamonroe

I especially hate Emily for the way James sings charity as charidee.

Emily is utter shit shit shit

[The Gutless Wonder]

I love those five songs. Nostalgic Pushead is great!

[less than zero]

I would defend nostalgic pushead to the last, not their finest hour admittedly but still good, brilliant opening line

[mooserevenge]

I bloody love all five songs, especially Year of Purification. Be Natural is a bit 'meh', but the others are fine to my ears.

Aren't opinions great?

[Son of Stopped]

2, 3 & 5 of Amanda's are the only ones I'd disagree with. And come to think of it, "asinine pricks" aside, I dread when that song plays on my internal jukebox. Underdogs hasn't got an "asinine pricks" bit, so my original choice still stands.