Forever Delayed - The Independent Manics Forum  

Go Back   Forever Delayed - The Independent Manics Forum > Manic Street Preachers > Manic Street Preachers Discussion

Reply
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
  #1  
Old 29-05-2013, 20:40
VCK's Avatar
VCK VCK is offline
Freed from the century
 
Join Date: Jan 2007
Location: Leeds
Age: 33
Posts: 560
What if the Manics broke up after The Holy Bible?

I've been thinking recently, if the Manics broke up after THB would the public perception of the band be different to how it is now? Would they be shrouded in some kind of mythology much like The Stone Roses and The Libertines have been? Would this mythology render them a much bigger name now than if they hadn't carried on and released career stunting albums such as Know Your Enemy and Lifeblood, due to inevitable eulogies from the music press, such as the NME, and fans who saw them telling people who didn't how "you had to be there"?

Just an interesting idea that I've pondered, much like how I've wondered what The Stone Roses and The Libertines would have been like if they hadn't split before they had a chance to become huge. Would they have released that album that would have catapulted them to superstardom, and would they have remained huge, or suffered a dip in popularity like the Manics did in the 00s?
__________________
There's not enough black in the Union Jack, there's so much white in the Stars And Stripes.
Reply With Quote
  #2  
Old 29-05-2013, 21:18
Lament's Avatar
Lament Lament is offline
I am purity, they call me perverted
 
Join Date: Sep 2004
Posts: 400
The Stone Roses and Libertines were much bigger than the Manics were right after THB. The Libertines had a #1 record and The Stone Roses had two top 5 records. Both had multiple top ten singles. In fact, both of those bands were nearly as big at their peak as the Manics were at theirs.
__________________
www.twitter.com/mlamentb
Reply With Quote
  #3  
Old 29-05-2013, 22:27
AK47's Avatar
AK47 AK47 is offline
A self-made vacuum
 
Join Date: Nov 2011
Location: In a leather bound book of the worlds greatest secrets
Posts: 2,253
No Autumnsong?
__________________
LET'S GO TO WAR!
Reply With Quote
  #4  
Old 29-05-2013, 22:28
Nature's Discontent Nature's Discontent is offline
Winterlover
 
Join Date: Jul 2009
Location: Back in the Eighties
Age: 34
Posts: 5,242
They would have become like Nirvana, complete with Sean forming a new band where he's the lead singer and guitarist
Reply With Quote
  #5  
Old 30-05-2013, 08:29
who's responsible?'s Avatar
who's responsible? who's responsible? is offline
I am purity, they call me perverted
 
Join Date: Feb 2012
Location: The Arse-end of Nowhere, Norfolk
Posts: 475
Interesting thought really.

I'd suggest they would have ended up an obscure footnote to the music of the early 90s. You have to take into account the fact that THB didn't exactly sell well, and it was only with the commercial success of EMG that they "got big" (if they ever really did). THB wasn't particularly well received; let's be honest, it was competing against the emergence of britpop acts. Oasis were releasing Definitely Maybe around the same time, yelling about Cigarettes and Alcohol at the same time MSP were singing about death camps. Speaking as a fan at that time, when THB was released it didn't really do it for me to the extent that GATS did. It was so dark that it took a while before I "got it" (and it was sharing my CD player with NIN's "The Downward Spiral" at the time, not exactly light and fluffy, but a lot easier to play than THB was),

From a personal view, they would have been just another band "I used to be into" in my early 20s, and I wouldn't have the same feelings about them as I actually do now. If they'd quit after THB they would not have been the providers of the soundtrack to my life that they have become, and my life would have been a little bit more empty for it.

Looking at it from the rock and roll myth perspective, what their status would have been would have been dependent on Richey. If they'd produced THB, then called it a day and Richey had managed to sort his head out then they would be one of many bands who flew too close to the sun, and got their wings melted by fame, then went off to live with their dogs somewhere. If the Richey story ended the same way, with his disappearance and then the band calling it a day, then they'd have ended up surrounded by mythology, the music press would be bringing them up periodically and asking "what if..?", and I don't think anyone would have blamed them for quitting at that point. As a fan at the time I didn't think they would carry on, they had basically imploded under the weight of their own product, but if they had quit, they'd have been remembered as a band who produced one damn fine album (THB) and a couple of pretty good ones, but were destroyed by the effort of making it. They hadn't really had the commercial success to be mythologised to the extent that the Roses were.

Must admit I'm liking ND's idea about Sean; think Richey's lyrics were dark? Imagine Sean's.......... (shudders in fear)...
__________________
Known for not much at all
Reply With Quote
  #6  
Old 30-05-2013, 10:15
Dac X Lee's Avatar
Dac X Lee Dac X Lee is offline
I live to fall asleep
 
Join Date: Jul 2012
Location: I live in Seoul (S. Korea), but I'm from Umag (Croatia)
Posts: 3,026
Quote:
Originally Posted by Nature's Discontent View Post
They would have become like Nirvana, complete with Sean forming a new band where he's the lead singer and guitarist
I think I quite agree with this.
But reading biographies and interviews, I think James would be the one to continue his career, if it's true his dream was that of becomming a rock star, after he gave up to be the next Napoleon.
__________________
100 0100 110 0001 111 0010 110 1001 110 0001
Reply With Quote
  #7  
Old 30-05-2013, 10:28
tzb's Avatar
tzb tzb is offline
Under neon loneliness
 
Join Date: Oct 2004
Posts: 34,152
Interesting idea. I suspect as you suggest they'd have become more of a cult band than they are these days, as they'd never have produced the big popular anthems ADFL and Tolerate. I can imagine them reforming to produce JFPL as well, which would only have cemented that reputation further (it really would be the ultimate reunion record, whereas despite reviewing well it passed relatively uncelebrated by the mainstream).

It also depends whether we're talking a post-Richey split, or if they decided to call it a day when he stopped being able to play live etc. It can't be denied his disappearance has played a large part in forming their "cult" legacy.
__________________
🜁 ᴛᴡᴏ ғɪɴɢᴇʀs ғᴏʀ ᴛʜᴇ ᴅᴇᴀᴅ | ᴛᴡᴏ ғɪɴɢᴇʀs ғᴏʀ ᴛʜᴇ ʟɪᴠɪɴɢ | ᴛᴡᴏ ғɪɴɢᴇʀs ғᴏʀ ᴛʜᴇ ᴡᴏʀʟᴅ ᴛʜᴀᴛ ᴡᴇ ᴀʟʟ ʟɪᴠᴇ ɪɴ
Reply With Quote
  #8  
Old 30-05-2013, 12:55
The Gutless Wonder's Avatar
The Gutless Wonder The Gutless Wonder is offline
Bored out of my mind
 
Join Date: Aug 2007
Location: World Headquarters of 'Team JDB' and CoJ
Posts: 42,921
Quote:
Originally Posted by AK47 View Post
No Autumnsong?
The reason they HAD to carry on!
__________________
"Former glam-punk rocker James Dean Bradfield now looks like your friendly, slightly rumpled Welsh uncle who always brings you chocolate when he visits. That's not a bad thing." - Allister Thompson aka The Gateless Gate (Canadian musician)
Reply With Quote
  #9  
Old 30-05-2013, 14:55
Nature's Discontent Nature's Discontent is offline
Winterlover
 
Join Date: Jul 2009
Location: Back in the Eighties
Age: 34
Posts: 5,242
Quote:
Originally Posted by Dac X Lee View Post
I think I quite agree with this.
But reading biographies and interviews, I think James would be the one to continue his career, if it's true his dream was that of becomming a rock star, after he gave up to be the next Napoleon.
On a more serious note, yes I'd agree with this. I reckon James would have done a couple of solo albums, along with producing the odd album like he would go on to do anyway with Northern Uproar.

With the band, I reckon they would still have become mythologised, but not any more so than they are now, as they would have remained slightly more unknown and obscure to the mainstream; and more people would have forgotten about them, like some of the other early/mid-90s bands they shared the same small level of success with.
Reply With Quote
  #10  
Old 30-05-2013, 15:45
Lone Architect's Avatar
Lone Architect Lone Architect is offline
Footprint of history
 
Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: Surrounded by other people's cats
Posts: 22,970
I possibly wouldn't be here. Not cos I don't like THB, GATS and GT, but because EMG was the first album I heard and I just don't think I'd have listened to any Manics at all until I was much older if it hadn't been for EMG/TIMT.

So yeah, glad they carried on.
Reply With Quote
  #11  
Old 30-05-2013, 15:58
VCK's Avatar
VCK VCK is offline
Freed from the century
 
Join Date: Jan 2007
Location: Leeds
Age: 33
Posts: 560
Some interesting replies here. I was too young to make any commentary on what their presence was like in the media so it's quite interesting to see. I always thought they were slightly bigger than they were during the Richey period. I know they earned a lot of pages in the NME etc.

Bearing in mind though that The Libertines weren't very big until they released Can't Stand Me Now and by that point everyone knew it was over. So I guess a more interesting question would be, what if they split up after Everything Must Go? Releasing one final album before calling it a day, and going out on a high? Maybe then they would have had Roses level eulogies, having broken up at the peak of their powers after releasing the perfect pop record.
__________________
There's not enough black in the Union Jack, there's so much white in the Stars And Stripes.
Reply With Quote
  #12  
Old 30-05-2013, 17:40
Manualex16 Manualex16 is offline
A self-made vacuum
 
Join Date: Sep 2011
Location: At the end of the universe
Posts: 2,138
I wouldn't have heard of them.
__________________
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ken Korda View Post
The Totoro plush but I suppose if I could only have the baby I could sell it to get the plush.
Beware!
Reply With Quote
  #13  
Old 30-05-2013, 20:38
Scarecrow's Avatar
Scarecrow Scarecrow is offline
Winterlover
 
Join Date: Oct 2006
Location: Up North
Age: 39
Posts: 6,629
If they'd broken up in 1995, I could imagine over time their story would become legendary, but I doubt that would've given them posthumous fame on a par with their late '90s fame. Would've made an interesting thing for people to stumble across years later, but of course, they just couldn't not make music together after that.
Reply With Quote
  #14  
Old 31-05-2013, 06:02
amnesic amnesic is offline
Knowlede Is Power
 
Join Date: Jan 2013
Posts: 1,040
I'm not sure whether I would have discovered them. I got into them just before Australia was released, after having read an article about them in Select and thought "they sound interesting" and went and bought GT
__________________
If I was in this family I'd drink too/Arrange your face/Biscuits!/There is no poetry in my heart/Time falls through my fingers
Reply With Quote
  #15  
Old 31-05-2013, 11:27
bigboots bigboots is offline
Bored of being bored
 
Join Date: Feb 2005
Location: Melbourne Australia
Age: 40
Posts: 1,974
They would probably have the same sort of mythology hype that Joy Division, Nirvana and The Libertines got. Because you can't predict what their follow-up albums would be like and its just a full stop being in top form. I guess the question is, should they have changed their band name like Joy Division did. The problem with that being that they didn't know if Richey would return some day. So it's completely understandable what they choose to do.

I think it's far more exciting to have all this great back catalogue of music though from the Manics. And they've still released great albums since then. Their physical image changed a bit. There is more of a maturity and mellowness to their post Holy Bible era.

James seemed quite nostalgic in the Holy Bible Anniversary interview dvd about being younger and things being exciting. I'm sure Richey leaving was quite a splinter for the band. But they soldiered on and didn't stop making music.
__________________
Reply With Quote
Reply

Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump


All times are GMT. The time now is 19:41.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.6
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.